Will public schools become red-headed stepchild?
by Marguerite Cline
November 02, 2012 12:00 AM | 4817 views | 5 5 comments | 22 22 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Usually I keep how I vote to myself. But this time it is different. I have already voted and I voted “No” on the charter school amendment. There is too much confusion surrounding it for me to be comfortable voting for it.

I am a strong supporter of public schools. Except for my college years, they have been a big part of my life. From my vantage point as a student, educator, mother and now as a grandmother, I am amazed by everything accomplished with our children.

Though it is widely debated, I am concerned that charter schools being funded with public funds will erode our existing system of public education. If the amendment passes, the money to fund them may well be taken away from our public schools.

There is a bad taste in my mouth because I have not seen anything guaranteeing me that charter schools would not get more dollars per student than the public schools do.

It makes me wonder, if the amendment passes, will our public schools become the proverbial red-headed stepchild of our state legislators when the money is doled out?

Four of my six grandchildren are in public schools. Two are home schooled. The choices their parents have made about their children’s education are working well for all of them.

When Joel and Anne made the decision to home school their children, they were well aware that both of the children could attend the public schools the taxpayers have provided for them.

They were well aware, too, that the costs of home schooling — and yes there are many — would come out of their pockets.

I often think of something Richard Rusk said his father, Cherokee Country native son and United States Secretary of State Dean Rusk told his children.

When the Rusk family moved to Washington, D.C., they attended public schools. Dean Rusk told his children, “Going to public schools is going to school with America.”

Something else that gnaws at me is this. Could this be the first step in another system of segregation of our schools? But this time it would not be separating blacks and whites.

It would be using public money to divide the haves from the have-nots. Maybe yes, maybe no. If so, it is a grave mistake.

I believe in local control and less government. I believe the closer to home decisions are made the better those decisions are. I also believe that our government is too big. We should be downsizing not adding on.

As I understand it, this amendment allows charter schools to bypass local Boards of Education and the State Board of Education. Charter schools would be under an appointed state charter school commission. That would be costly and is unnecessary.

We already have a local Board of Education and a State Board of Education. You and I elected our local board. We have charged them with ensuring that every child in Cherokee County is provided an appropriate education.

If you or I are not pleased with a decision made by the Cherokee Board of Education, we can appeal to the State Board of Education. Then, if we still are not satisfied, we can take it to court for a judge to make a decision.

And, not to be forgotten, is that when the majority of the public does not agree with the actions of the BOE, we know how to vote them out of office and elect others who will follow the wishes of those they represent. With a specially appointed state commission, we have no recourse regarding their decision.

Some people tell us the charter school amendment will give parents choices about the kind of school our children can attend.

In Georgia we have public schools, private schools, church schools, charter schools and home schools. We have all of them here in Cherokee. Parents already have choices. But the rub is, if the amendment passes, you and I will be paying for students to go to charter schools. Parents of students in private schools, church schools and home schools will continue to pay for the choice they have made.

Usually, I do not complain about the money I pay in taxes. This time is different. We are being asked to pay for something we already are paying — educational opportunities for all of Georgia’s children.

Paying for something twice is not something I want to do.

Now if anyone is fuming because of my comment about red-headed stepchildren, please remember that is just an expression. I have a beautiful, red-headed grandchild named Laney and would welcome a red-headed stepchild, too.

Marguerite Cline is the former mayor of Waleska.
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Have & Have Not
November 06, 2012
Ms. Cline get your head out of the sand. You don't have to wait for the passage of the charter school amendment to pass for schools to be segregated between the have and have not's because they already are. Even in the very county that you live and have worked in Cherokee County. Just compare Etowah which is supported by the well to do Towne Lake community with it's low population of free / reduced meal students, higher test county scores on most standardized tests and million dollar artificial football field as compared to Cherokee with it's high student population of free / reduced meals, low county results on most standardized test's and painted natural grass dying football field. I'm all for as a concerned parent that I have greater choices for my children's education which charter school's will provide and not limit their opportunity for educational success because of the boundary lines that a monopoly / money driven school board assigns us to. After looking at the results of today's voting so do the majority of the voters of this county by a 60% - 40% margin.
Loving Mom
November 04, 2012
"There is a bad taste in my mouth because I have not seen anything guaranteeing me that charter schools would not get more dollars per student than the public schools do."

Really?! Not only do charter schools not get more dollars than local schools, they get LESS. Because the local tax dollars for each student goes to his/her district school even though that child does not attend. This is not about money. This is about children and giving parents options.

Cale Collins
November 03, 2012
Please make your arguments clear...

PUBLIC FUNDS does not equal LOCAL FUNDS...no Cherokee Co. Funds will be given to Charter Schools if the amendment passes...

Second, the LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD is not BY-PASSED...EVERY potential CHARTER SCHOOL STILL has to go through he LOCAL Board and only if they are DENIED are they allowed to APPEAL to the STATE!

NO additional dollars will be taken from you or me personally if the amendment passes...and I think since the Cherokee Co School System failed my son I/he should have the RIGHT to his STATE PROVIDED FUNDS and they be used in the CHARTER SCHOOL of our CHOICE!
Christine Eltz
November 02, 2012
Thank you, Marguerite, for putting so eloquently into words what I could not!
Alan A
November 02, 2012
Ms. Cline, I appreciate your article so very much. Additionally, I agree with everything you are saying and I also voted "No".

One of the biggest questions that I have would be - how much, if any of the tax dollars from Cherokee Co. go to Charter Schools USA, in Fort Lauderdale, Fl? I'm just curious as to whether a portion of our local tax dollars go to CSUSA to pay salaries.

Thanks for any clarification you can provide.

*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides